Kohler, A. (2015). Carving the Brain at its Joints - A Commentary on Michael L. Anderson
نویسندگان
چکیده
When neuroscientists explain the biological basis of a phenomenon of interest, they usually try to identify the parts of a system that seem do the relevant job, and propose a model of how those parts interact to produce the phenomenon. This mechanistic framework of explanation is widely used and has been investigated from a philosophical point of view by different authors. In his target article, Michael Anderson poses a challenge to the currently dominant version of mechanistic explanation as advocated, e.g., by Carl Craver. Taking empirical results and explanatory models from studies on retinal starburst amacrine cells as a starting point, Anderson suggests that the current framework for mechanistic explanation should be extended to include a differentiation between systems and mechanisms, which would allow more leeway in understanding processing in the nervous system. Mechanisms can then be seen to provide enabling constraints on the functioning of systems, where the mechanisms do not need to be subsumed under the system and do not even have to be on the same organizational level. Although Anderson’s proposal is interesting and worth exploring, I am unconvinced that this extension conforms to real-world explanatory practice and/or is necessary for accommodating the understanding of direction-selectivity in the retina. I examine another sample of research on starburst amacrine cells, where the integration of empirical data and computational models shows that, on close inspection, it is distributed networks to which certain characteristics are ascribed—a situation that can be handled with the available tools of mechanistic explanation.
منابع مشابه
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition Carving Executive Control at Its Joints: Working Memory Capacity Predicts Stimulus–Stimulus, But Not Stimulus–Response, Conflict
متن کامل
Improved Content Aware Image Retargeting Using Strip Partitioning
Based on rapid upsurge in the demand and usage of electronic media devices such as tablets, smart phones, laptops, personal computers, etc. and its different display specifications including the size and shapes, image retargeting became one of the key components of communication technology and internet. The existing techniques in image resizing cannot save the most valuable information of image...
متن کاملModifications to Walker-Anderson Model for Analysis of High-velocity Penetration of an Eroding Long-rod Projectile into Semi-infinite Concrete Targets
This paper presents a modified form of the Walker-Anderson (W-A) model for analyzing high velocity penetration of an eroding projectile into a concrete target in which the W-A model is improved by incorporating calculations for the plastic flow field of concrete in terms of its compressibility and strain rate sensitivity under severe pressure. With the changes to and calculations of plastic fie...
متن کاملCarving Nature at Its Joints and Carving Joints into Nature: How Labels Augment Category Representations
Using words to label categories is a true human universal. In addition to their public function in communication, labels may also serve private functions in shaping how concepts are represented. The present work explored the effects of assigning category labels on perceptual representations. A connectionist simulation is presented that examines the effects of labels on learning different types ...
متن کاملCommentary: New View on Treatment of Drug Dependence
In the 1960s, discovery of pleasure system (defined as reward system) in the brain that may underlie drug reward and addiction encouraged many scientists to investigate the mechanisms by which drug abuse affects central nervous system function. In this regard, investigators developed several drugs targeting the brain reward system for drug dependence therapy. However, no positive results obtain...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2015